Image


Welcome – you are in:
South Beach Diet - Phase 2

WEEK # 13 MEETING (MArch 29, 2010) at 12 PM EST

Zebra_2's Avatar
From: Zebra_2
To: ALL     Edited: Mar-29 11:38 AM (1 of 45)
Topic of the Week: Make Peace With the Scale or Find Your Healthy Weight

What is a healthy weight? How can one make peace with the scale? As many people know, as you're trying to lose weight, the scale is your go-to source of your progress. But there are other ways to measure success--for example, how your clothes fit, how you feel (e.g. stronger, more energized), or the simple fact that you don't lose your breath after walking up a flight of stairs.

Plus, there are ways you can reward yourself (non-food related, of course!) that can help improve your body image and keep you motivated.

How do you measure your success? Share with us today!

Our guest this week is Kathy Hewes, MS, RD, LDN. Kathy Hewes is a registered and licensed dietitian with more than twenty years experience in the fields of nutrition and exercise science. Her areas of professional experience include sports nutrition, senior nutrition, and working in the health and wellness community. Welcome, Kathy!

Dietitian_Kathleen's Avatar
To: ALL     Edited: Mar-29 11:35 AM (2 of 45)
In reply to this post

Thanks, Laurie!

This is something we all struggle with, what is a healthy weight? You step on the scale and the number is rarely where you’d like it to be. For many, stepping onto the scale is akin to a roller coaster ride. Sometimes you’re elated and flying high at your accomplishments, sometimes it’s frustration and wondering why all you’re hard work isn’t showing up in the numbers.

There are things we can all do to alleviate some of the ups and downs each time we step onto the scale:

1) Always use the same scale, in the same location (placed on a hard surface, not a rug), dressed in the same way, and at the same time of day. Try to avoid the temptation to jump on the scale at the mall, in your best friend’s bathroom or even at the gym. Scales in public places are rarely calibrated and will give you inaccurate reading.

2) Fluctuations in weight happen! It’s a fact of being human and how we digest, store and eliminate the foods we eat. Weight can be up one day due to a higher sodium intake, more starches than usual, or even because it’s time for monthly hormonal swings. These types of changes are due to water retention and are not because we’ve gained fat weight.

3) Look to other methods of assessing accomplishments other than the scale. How we feel can be a great indicator of how things are going. Using tape measurements at several areas on the body will show how we’re losing fat, gaining muscle and becoming more fit.

Ask yourself some of these questions:

Can you climb the stairs without getting out of breath?

Can you pick up groceries or grandkids with confidence?

Do your clothes fit more comfortably?

Are you able to pull your belt in a notch?

Can you now lower your medication dosage, or take fewer medications?

Do you feel more in control of your body, how it moves and responds when asked to perform daily tasks?

However you measure you’re progress, reward yourself with something that allows you to celebrate where you are along your journey. Perhaps a new exercise outfit (a new pair of walking shoes can invigorate your workout), some new music to move to or maybe a weekend spa retreat to really rev-up your spirits.

Your tool kit for measuring progress should contain more than weekly weigh-ins. Success comes in many forms and can be measured in many ways, so try something different if the dial is getting stuck in one spot. The scale holds a small place in the bigger picture of a happier, healthier you. Decide to marvel at what your body can do, discard the negative thoughts, make peace with the scale and move on!

I'd love to hear everyone's thoughts! And who has questions about this topic?

Zebra_2's Avatar
From: Zebra_2
To: Dietitian_Kathleen     Posted: Mar-29 12:04 PM (3 of 45)
In reply to this post
Since I am comming up on 3 years on South Beach I have had to learn this lesson. The scale is one means of feedback to an ever changing picture. I use it as one tool only and check in to see if I am on target or need to be more aware of what I am eating. Getting away from it's ability to tell me what I deserve is a huge accomplishment for anyone. I hope others are finding the ability to take control of that scale too !

Your suggestions are indeed helpful !

L
Zebra_2's Avatar
From: Zebra_2
To: ALL     Posted: Mar-29 12:06 PM (4 of 45)
In reply to this post

Kathleen -

Some of us use the BMI measures as a way to know how we are doing but recent discussions suggest that waist circumference is a better measure. Any comments on that?

L

Zebra_2's Avatar
From: Zebra_2
To: ALL     Posted: Mar-29 12:10 PM (5 of 45)
In reply to this post

Changing behaviors is hard. I find myself still using food to reward myself. The difference with South Beach is it is now 0 % fat Greek Yogurt with Agave and cinnamon  not ice creme. Substitutions has made this bearable for me long term. Of course, it is probably better to solve the behavior- but that seems to be alot harder!

L

Zebra_2's Avatar
From: Zebra_2
To: ALL     Posted: Mar-29 12:15 PM (6 of 45)
In reply to this post

Don't forget to weigh in this week !


Also Hit F5 to refresh the screen so you can see the chat today  !

geemamaak's Avatar
From: geemamaak
To: Dietitian_Kathleen     Posted: Mar-29 12:15 PM (7 of 45)
In reply to this post
Hello Laurie and Kathleen,
Thanks again for choosing a very relevant topic.  Last week I noticed that almost all of my work clothes were literally falling off me - I purchased them last October and have since lost about fifteen pounds.  Since spring is coming anyway, I decided to buy some new clothes and when I went to the store, found out I was a size six in almost every style.  I am happy at this size, but I am a good twenty pounds heavier than my goal weight - still smack in the middle of "overweight" by the BMI calculators.   So my question is, if I like the way I look and feel now (BP is hovering just above normal, blood chemistry is great), but I am overweight by any objective measure, when should  I go into maintenance mode?
    Thanks!
Dietitian_Kathleen's Avatar
To: Zebra_2     Posted: Mar-29 12:19 PM (8 of 45)
In reply to this post
Zebra_2 wrote: "Since I am coming up on 3 years on South Beach I have had to learn this lesson. The scale is one means of feedback to an ever changing picture. I use it as one tool only and check in to see if I am on target or need to be more aware of what I am eating. Getting away from it's ability to tell me what I deserve is a huge accomplishment for anyone. I hope others are finding the ability to take control of that scale too! Some of us use the BMI measures as a way to know how we are doing but recent discussions suggest that waist circumference is a better measure. Any comments on that?"


You are correct, the scale should be used as one tool in your arsenal of knowledge about living a healthier lifestyle. Weighing in regularly and using that information for guidance can prove very helpful when living your life, rather than being tied to a number.
 
There are several other tools to measure success. The BMI charts that are available give you information pertaining to how your weight corresponds to your height. Another tool is waist circumference measures. High risk for women is greater than 35 inches for women, 40 inches for men. A high waist circumference is associated with increased risk for Type 2 diabetes, problems with blood lipids, hypertension and cardiovascular disease.
 
It is wise to use a variety of tools when determining where you are and where you want to be.
Zebra_2's Avatar
From: Zebra_2
To: Dietitian_Kathleen     Posted: Mar-29 12:23 PM (9 of 45)
In reply to this post
Thanks Kathleen-
I suspect too , the more tools you use , the more objective you can be about where you should be. Dr. A comments ocassionally on the Cosmos effect. Some folks are not happy even when they are at a healthy weight? Is that what that means ?
L
Zebra_2's Avatar
From: Zebra_2
To: geemamaak     Posted: Mar-29 12:25 PM (10 of 45)
In reply to this post

Thanks for joining us. I think Kathleen is commenting on that subject right now. For me, I am not at goal yet but I do plan to see how I feel and even if I am on the higher side, If I am fit  and able to do what I want, and my blood work is good, I will let those things be my guide.

L

YellowRose0916's Avatar
To: Dietitian_Kathleen     Posted: Mar-29 12:25 PM (11 of 45)
In reply to this post

We were just talking about the scale on the E & F board this week.  Several of us, for various reasons, weigh every day -- regardless of the fact that we've been told it's better not to.  But I can weigh every day because if it doesn't show a loss, or even shows a small gain, it's not discouraging for me.  I know that weight flucuates based on whether you've had something with a lot of sodium in it, or if it's that time of the month, or if I'm doing weight training -- or maybe I hit a plateau.

But I do have other measures of success, as you said.  I take my measurements at the beginning of each month.  I've had to buy some smaller size pants to wear to work, and I can wear a pair of jeans that's been in the back of my dresser for several years now.  All these things keep me motivated -- if one thing isn't improving, I always have something else I can look at and say, "Yes, that's better than it was before!" 

Zebra_2's Avatar
From: Zebra_2
To: YellowRose0916     Posted: Mar-29 12:29 PM (12 of 45)
In reply to this post

Thanks for joining us Linda. I love that you have several things to fall back on to get support. Loose pants is a wonderful one. I remember after working out at the gym one day I looked at my thighs and did not reconized how much smaller they were. That was a measurement moment too !  We just need to stop, look and give ourselves credit sometimes !

L

Dietitian_Kathleen's Avatar
To: geemamaak     Posted: Mar-29 12:31 PM (13 of 45)
In reply to this post
geemamaak wrote: "Thanks again for choosing a very relevant topic.  Last week I noticed that almost all of my work clothes were literally falling off me - I purchased them last October and have since lost about fifteen pounds.  Since spring is coming anyway, I decided to buy some new clothes and when I went to the store, found out I was a size six in almost every style.  I am happy at this size, but I am a good twenty pounds heavier than my goal weight - still smack in the middle of "overweight" by the BMI calculators.   So my question is, if I like the way I look and feel now (BP is hovering just above normal, blood chemistry is great), but I am overweight by any objective measure, when should  I go into maintenance mode?"


First, congratulations on your success. I think you and I are cut from the same cloth! I too weigh more than the charts say I should, but I'm happy in a size six, and have been for a very long time.
 
One thing to consider is that the number on the scale is NOT the only number in town. You mentioned your blood work is all good, those numbers are important to consider too. One other number to think about is your body composition. Have you ever had your body fat measured? If you've been exercising you could carry more lean muscle than fat weight, and the scale won't indicate this. 
 
If you are happy where you are, and you are healthy, then consider it time to maintain your current fitness and health levels. Enjoy your new wardrobe, and the Spring weather!
YellowRose0916's Avatar
To: Zebra_2     Posted: Mar-29 12:35 PM (14 of 45)
In reply to this post
Unfortunately, that's one thing I haven't been able to improve.  I am beginning to see other things as rewards -- new clothes, for example.  But still, food has the upper hand.  And it's not going to be good, like your choice.  Reaching goals means a trip to my favorite Mexican restaurant.  I do make better choices there -- chicken fajitas instead of the enchilada dinner, and most of the time, I don't eat the tortillas.  But I'm going to have the chips and hot sauce, and I don't care how long I'm going to have to walk later to make up for it. 

So I still have room for improvement in that area!!
Dietitian_Kathleen's Avatar
To: Zebra_2     Posted: Mar-29 12:35 PM (15 of 45)
In reply to this post
Zebra_2 wrote: "I suspect too , the more tools you use, the more objective you can be about where you should be. Dr. A comments ocassionally on the Cosmo effect. Some folks are not happy even when they are at a healthy weight? Is that what that means?"


Absolutely! Information is power, and being constrained by one measure is not what life is all about. Weight fluctuates from one day to the next, and we need to realize that we are more than the sum of our parts. Finding peace with ourselves and our size can be very liberating. I cannot speak for Dr. A, but I'm sure he has something like that in mind when he uses that phrase.
YellowRose0916's Avatar
To: Zebra_2     Posted: Mar-29 12:38 PM (16 of 45)
In reply to this post
That's another one I had forgotten.  Usually by this time, I would have had to buy another pair of the exercise pants I wear to walk in because I would have worn out the inner thighs from my legs rubbing together as I walk.  The ones I have got a little worn in the beginning, but now my thighs are small enough that they don't rub -- at least not as much.
Zebra_2's Avatar
From: Zebra_2
To: YellowRose0916     Posted: Mar-29 12:39 PM (17 of 45)
In reply to this post
I know what you mean. Just as removing food from the kitchen that is tempting, I also do not go to certain places that I can not resist. Or like Sushi, which I just have to have white rice, I minimize the damage as you did and eat more sashimi than the rolls that have the rice.
Avoid trigger foods, minimize damage , get it out of reach !
L
Dietitian_Kathleen's Avatar
To: YellowRose0916     Posted: Mar-29 12:40 PM (18 of 45)
In reply to this post
YellowRose0916 wrote: "We were just talking about the scale on the E & F board this week.  Several of us, for various reasons, weigh every day -- regardless of the fact that we've been told it's better not to.  But I can weigh every day because if it doesn't show a loss, or even shows a small gain, it's not discouraging for me.  I know that weight flucuates based on whether you've had something with a lot of sodium in it, or if it's that time of the month, or if I'm doing weight training -- or maybe I hit a plateau. But I do have other measures of success, as you said.  I take my measurements at the beginning of each month.  I've had to buy some smaller size pants to wear to work, and I can wear a pair of jeans that's been in the back of my dresser for several years now.  All these things keep me motivated -- if one thing isn't improving, I always have something else I can look at and say, 'Yes, that's better than it was before!'"


I am so glad that you are seeking out information to support your efforts, rather than focusing on the number on the scale alone. If you can weigh yourself daily and it doesn't affect your mood or positive outlook, then that's fine. The scale doesn't have to be our enemy. Congratulations on your success! 
Zebra_2's Avatar
From: Zebra_2
To: YellowRose0916     Posted: Mar-29 12:41 PM (19 of 45)
In reply to this post

Ha, HA. You mae me laugh cause the reverse works too. My legs started rubbing again the other day and I said to myself" Oh that is where those 5 lbs went . ( I picked up some this winter ! Needlesstosay I am on P1 (modified to 1 starch 1 fruit ) this week !

LOL

L

winefairie's Avatar
From: winefairie
To: Zebra_2     Posted: Mar-29 12:44 PM (20 of 45)
In reply to this post
I love to garden. I'm rewarding myself with new plants for my yard.  Not only isn't it food (I love food!) but I have to get outside and plant them!
Zebra_2's Avatar
From: Zebra_2
To: Dietitian_Kathleen     Posted: Mar-29 12:45 PM (21 of 45)
In reply to this post
I like to ask this of other guests as the answers are always different and give us clues what NOT to do.  Why do you think most people fail on diets ?

They say the diet wars are over, do you feel people are understanding nutrition more these days ?
L